Building an Experiment Review Sheet
Standardize post-run audits with structured checklist protocols for data entry validation, outlier screening, and residual diagnostic verification.

Contents Overview
Why Use a Review Sheet
A review sheet is a short, structured record that travels with an experiment. It makes the plan, the execution and the analysis checkable by someone who was not in the room.
It also helps the experimenter catch problems such as missing runs, changed settings or data entry errors before they affect conclusions.
Key Principle
The effect of one factor may depend on the level of another.
What to Include
Record the objective, the response and how it is measured, each factor with its levels and the reason for them, the design type, the number of replicates, and the randomized run order actually used.
After the runs, note deviations from the plan, unusual observations, and the results of residual checks for normality, constant variance and independence.
Using the Sheet in Review
Reviewers can compare the planned and actual run order, confirm that the analysed data match the recorded data, and see whether the conclusions stay within the tested ranges.
Keep the sheet with the worksheet and analysis output so the full chain from plan to conclusion is preserved.
Swipe to view all columns
| Review item | What to record |
|---|---|
| Objective & response | Question being asked; response and measurement method |
| Factors & levels | Each factor, its levels and the reason for the range |
| Design | Type, number of runs, replicates, center points |
| Execution | Randomized run order used; deviations from plan |
| Analysis checks | Residual plots reviewed; conclusions within tested range |
Key Takeaways
- Document objective, factors, levels, design and run order.
- Record deviations and unusual observations as they happen.
- Check residual diagnostics before drawing conclusions.